Omnes Sancti et Sanctæ Coreæ, orate pro nobis.

Now Blogging Afresh at Ad Orientem 西儒 - The Western Confucian



Wednesday, December 14, 2005

Against Torture
In THE TORTURE DEBATE, Maggie Gallagher takes the morally correct stand:
    I have found few things more distressing than discovering so many of my fellow citizens support not just harsh interrogation techniques, but outright torture....

    The Wall Street Journal opines: "A strange code of morality would allow the killing of (a known terrorist) but not his stressful questioning to prevent further murders he might plan against innocent civilians. "

    Let me tell you about that strange code. It used to be called "Christianity." For centuries it chiefly justified deadly force only in self-defense, or the proper defense of another. When a terrorist is out there trying to kill you, you may be justified in using deadly force. But once you capture him, then different moral rules apply. Others once referred to this strange moral code as "civilization." Its veneer over the human heart is razor-thin. Under threat, most of us revert to the primitive ethic: Hurt the bad guy.
According to an article entitled MAJORITY SUPPORT TORTURE, to which I linked yesterday, "90 percent of South Koreans... support the use of torture." This really doesn't surprise me, as the East has always placed the community above the individual. The same article notes that "61 percent of Americans... support the use of torture," which doesn't really surprise me either.

For more on this topic, see these articles: